We solve serious CRA tax problems

Limitations When Claiming Business Expenses

Business Expense Limitations

In an earlier article, a list of business expense categories used by the CRA was provided (see the article HERE). This is the second article in the series that hopes to help small business owners figure out what expenses are deductible and which ones are not. In this article, we are going to start by looking at the most common limitations on the deductibility of expenses in the Income Tax Act. One general limitation discussed in a separate article is that the expense has to be reasonable in amount and in substance (see that article HERE).

So, once you have removed the HST/GST portion, determined that the expense is reasonable, and that it is something that should be deducted to get to “profit”, are you good to deduct? The answer is “No!”. The Income Tax Act has a series of limitations that apply to all expenses with respect to business and property sources of income. There are much more restrictive limits for employment expenses, but that is for another article. The most common general limitations on business expenses, or tax deductions, are found in section 18 of the Income Tax Act. There are too many limits to address in one article, so we are going to focus on the most common ones that small businesses encounter.

The most important limit is also the first one listed in section 18. It says that NO amount is deductible unless the outlay was made or the expense was incurred by the taxpayer (being the person whose business or property profit we are calculating) “for the purpose of gaining or producing income from the business or property”. There is a lot to digest in these few words. The most important thing to notice is that it is a “purpose” test, not a “results” test. So long as the “purpose” of incurring the expenditure is to make income, it doesn’t matter whether that specific expenditure produces revenues or a profit (or even if the business itself is profitable). This makes sense since a business can have a loss year one tax-year and a profitable year in another tax-year. If expenses were not deductible unless there was a profit directly related to the expense, a business could never suffer losses. In other words, there is no need to show a causal connection between an expense and revenue or income. That said, this is not purely subjective. The expense must be part of the business – somehow related to the operations, transactions, or services by which the business earns revenue. If an ordinary person in that line of business would have incurred the expense as part of the business, then the purpose test is met.

The second limitation on what expenses are deductible relates to capital expenses. Despite accounting practice, you cannot deduct fully and all at once any expense that is “capital” in nature or that relates to “depreciation, obsolescence or depletion”. Where you incur an expense that gives you a lasting benefit ? where the expense is “capital” and not just operational ? then all deductions are only those the allowed by the Income Tax Act. Most of this is covered by the Capital Cost Allowance system that will be discussed in another article.

The next limit on expense deductibility we consider is that you cannot an expense that relates to producing exempt income. This makes sense. If the profits are not going to be taxable, why would the expenses (or resulting losses) be deductible?

The fourth limitation is one that many small business owners get caught by. The law doesn’t allow any deduction for “personal or living expenses”. The only exception to this is any personal or living expenses that are “travel expenses” incurred while away from home and traveling on business. There are some other expenses that are “personal and living” expenses that are specifically allowed. These specific expenses will be covered in the final part of this article series (coming soon).

The fourth limitation is one that many small business owners get caught by. The law doesn’t allow any deduction for “personal or living expenses”. The only exception to this is any personal or living expenses that are “travel expenses” incurred while away from home and traveling on business. There are some other expenses that are “personal and living” expenses that are specifically allowed. These specific expenses will be covered in the final part of this article series (coming soon).

  1. Is the expense widely accepted in the business community as a business expense?
  2. Is the deduction for this expense one that is ordinarily allowed as a business expense by accountants?
  3. Is the expense one that is regularly incurred by others that are involved in the same business?
  4. Would this particular expense have arisen if you were not involved in the business you are involved in?

Where the expense would have been incurred if you were not engaged in the business or, in other words, where the need for the expense exists independent of the specific business, then the expense is most likely one that is “personal or living”. A good example of this is ordinary clothing as compared to specific uniforms or specialized clothing. Whether or not a person is involved in any business or not, they will have to pay for clothing. This is just one of those expenses of living that has to be incurred no matter what. However, some items of clothing are either required as a uniform for a business, and therefore cannot be work elsewhere, or are specialized clothing (reflective vests, safety equipment, heavy duty work wear, etc.) that a person would not buy absent the specific needs of a business. The cost of this clothing would be deductible (though most likely the cost would be a capital expense). Another common example is the cost of travel to and from your place of business. Everyone needs to get to and from work, no matter what their work is (or whether they are employed or in business), and the cost of getting to work (and the choice of the transportation method) is a personal one.

To summarize so far, in order for an expense to be deductible it:

  • Must be reasonable,
  • Must be incurred for the purpose of producing income,
  • Must NOT be a capital expense,
  • Must NOT be related to earning exempt income, and
  • Must NOT be a personal or living expense.

The next article will discuss limits on a set of specific expenses.

About the Author

pro-tip

Pro Tip

ACCESSING THE SMALL BUSINESS DEDUCTION IN YOUR BUSINESS

The Small Business Deduction gives businesses a tax deduction on the first $500,000 of income. This saves an eligible corporation around up to $50,000 in income taxes. There are a number of conditions that have to be met to be eligible for this deduction.

Great experience with Sam!
Response from the owner:Hello Dasha Thank you for the five stars review and your kind words. It was a pleasure working with you and I am glad that we met your expectations. Please feel free to reach out to us if you need to in the future. Many thanks Sam Faris
I was so impressed with Sam's professionalism and how quickly he reacted to my inquiries. His knowledge was evident, and he handled everything expertly. I highly recommend his services.
Response from the owner:Mohamed Thank you for the 5 stars Google review and your kind words. Our goal is always to make the process efficient and the workflow as smooth as possible. We are glad that we met your expectations and we will remain at your disposal at anyone in the future. Sam Faris
Thank you for all your help! Quick and stress free! Definitely recommended!
Response from the owner:Thank you DD for the 5 star positive review. We were happy to work on your file and get you positive results. We will remain at your disposal in the future if needed. Thanks Sam Faris
Sam and his team helped me to file my multiple outstanding personal and corporate tax returns. He was able to save me from legal action by the CRA, saved me taxes and CRA waived the penalties for me. I highly recommend his services for any tax help and CRA audit needs.
Response from the owner:Ms. Rivera Your 5 stars Google review is very much appreciated. I am glad that we met your expectations and you are happy with our work quality and the outcome achieved. We are specialized in filling multiple years of outstanding personal and corporate tax returns. We have helped many clients for more than 15 years to file all their outstanding tax returns in the most efficient way. We were able to get them out of troubles with the CRA, save them taxes, waiving penalties and get them interest relief. We take a pride of what we do and our team is fully dedicated and experienced to deal with any type of dispute with the CRA. We are at your disposal anytime you need us in the future. Sam Faris
Faris CPA took care of my tax audit case by the CRA. The team performed the work on timely basis and in the most efficient way possible. End results are beyond expectations. Hire Faris CPA and they will do the required work with reasonable fee.
Response from the owner:Many thanks Andrea for your positive review and I am glad that you are happy with our services. Our firm is specialized in all kind of tax disputes with the CRA including tax audits. All our staff are CPAs who have many years of experience in fighting the CRA. Thanks again and please feel free to reach out to us in the future if needed. Sam Faris
I found Sam online and I decided to have a consultation with him to discuss my CRA audit. I got a very good feeling about him, his integrity and his tax knowledge and skills and I had no doubts that he would be the best fit to provide audit help and support. I decided to hire him to handle my case. His approach to my case was consistent to the advice that he gave me at the conclusion. Sam was able to prepare working papers and supporting documents to show the auditor why his numbers are overstated. Sam had to involve the team leader and insisted to meet with him as the auditor refused to adjust his numbers. Sam confidently presented his work to the team leader and the team leader accepted his numbers without any adjustments. Sam deserves 10 stars for all what he has done in my CRA audit case and all his support and help.
Response from the owner:Thank you for the 5 stars review and your kind words. I am glad that we met your expectations. Please feel free to reach out to us if you require further help in the future.
Thank you Sam for your guidance and walking me through the implication of being taxed in Canada as a US resident. You help is very helpful and informative.
Response from the owner:It’s was my pleasure Mr. Makhoul. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to explain your matter and we look forward to further help you in the future.
I am very grateful to Mr. Faris and his team. I appreciate their expertise, support and professionalism in my most difficult time in life fighting the CRA. They were always made me feel that I am in a good hands and the results that they got very impressive. If you have any problem with the CRA, hire Faris CPA as they are top notch tax firm.
Response from the owner:Thank you Michael for the positive review. We always make sure to pay attention to details and to provide the best service with top quality work to perfectly defend clients with the CRA. Our work is based on many years of experience in helping clients with all different types of audits. Our firm consists of CPAs who have many years of experience in dealing with CRA audits. We are confident with our work and confident that we can provide second to none service. Thanks again Sam Faris
I recently had a consultation with Mr. Faris regarding a CRA audit. He was very knowledgeable. He helped me to get a fair understanding of my situation and reduced my stress level by suggesting a very good approach to address the audit and how to eliminate unfavorable audit results.
Response from the owner:Mr. Singh Thank you for the positive review and your kind words. I am glad that I met your expectations and provided answers to all your questions. We are a firm who is fully dedicated to solve all kind of problems with the CRA. Please feel free to contact us if you need further help in the future. Thanks Sam Faris