We solve serious CRA tax problems

Limitations When Claiming Business Expenses

Business Expense Limitations

In an earlier article, a list of business expense categories used by the CRA was provided (see the article HERE). This is the second article in the series that hopes to help small business owners figure out what expenses are deductible and which ones are not. In this article, we are going to start by looking at the most common limitations on the deductibility of expenses in the Income Tax Act. One general limitation discussed in a separate article is that the expense has to be reasonable in amount and in substance (see that article HERE).

So, once you have removed the HST/GST portion, determined that the expense is reasonable, and that it is something that should be deducted to get to “profit”, are you good to deduct? The answer is “No!”. The Income Tax Act has a series of limitations that apply to all expenses with respect to business and property sources of income. There are much more restrictive limits for employment expenses, but that is for another article. The most common general limitations on business expenses, or tax deductions, are found in section 18 of the Income Tax Act. There are too many limits to address in one article, so we are going to focus on the most common ones that small businesses encounter.

The most important limit is also the first one listed in section 18. It says that NO amount is deductible unless the outlay was made or the expense was incurred by the taxpayer (being the person whose business or property profit we are calculating) “for the purpose of gaining or producing income from the business or property”. There is a lot to digest in these few words. The most important thing to notice is that it is a “purpose” test, not a “results” test. So long as the “purpose” of incurring the expenditure is to make income, it doesn’t matter whether that specific expenditure produces revenues or a profit (or even if the business itself is profitable). This makes sense since a business can have a loss year one tax-year and a profitable year in another tax-year. If expenses were not deductible unless there was a profit directly related to the expense, a business could never suffer losses. In other words, there is no need to show a causal connection between an expense and revenue or income. That said, this is not purely subjective. The expense must be part of the business – somehow related to the operations, transactions, or services by which the business earns revenue. If an ordinary person in that line of business would have incurred the expense as part of the business, then the purpose test is met.

The second limitation on what expenses are deductible relates to capital expenses. Despite accounting practice, you cannot deduct fully and all at once any expense that is “capital” in nature or that relates to “depreciation, obsolescence or depletion”. Where you incur an expense that gives you a lasting benefit ? where the expense is “capital” and not just operational ? then all deductions are only those the allowed by the Income Tax Act. Most of this is covered by the Capital Cost Allowance system that will be discussed in another article.

The next limit on expense deductibility we consider is that you cannot an expense that relates to producing exempt income. This makes sense. If the profits are not going to be taxable, why would the expenses (or resulting losses) be deductible?

The fourth limitation is one that many small business owners get caught by. The law doesn’t allow any deduction for “personal or living expenses”. The only exception to this is any personal or living expenses that are “travel expenses” incurred while away from home and traveling on business. There are some other expenses that are “personal and living” expenses that are specifically allowed. These specific expenses will be covered in the final part of this article series (coming soon).

The fourth limitation is one that many small business owners get caught by. The law doesn’t allow any deduction for “personal or living expenses”. The only exception to this is any personal or living expenses that are “travel expenses” incurred while away from home and traveling on business. There are some other expenses that are “personal and living” expenses that are specifically allowed. These specific expenses will be covered in the final part of this article series (coming soon).

  1. Is the expense widely accepted in the business community as a business expense?
  2. Is the deduction for this expense one that is ordinarily allowed as a business expense by accountants?
  3. Is the expense one that is regularly incurred by others that are involved in the same business?
  4. Would this particular expense have arisen if you were not involved in the business you are involved in?

Where the expense would have been incurred if you were not engaged in the business or, in other words, where the need for the expense exists independent of the specific business, then the expense is most likely one that is “personal or living”. A good example of this is ordinary clothing as compared to specific uniforms or specialized clothing. Whether or not a person is involved in any business or not, they will have to pay for clothing. This is just one of those expenses of living that has to be incurred no matter what. However, some items of clothing are either required as a uniform for a business, and therefore cannot be work elsewhere, or are specialized clothing (reflective vests, safety equipment, heavy duty work wear, etc.) that a person would not buy absent the specific needs of a business. The cost of this clothing would be deductible (though most likely the cost would be a capital expense). Another common example is the cost of travel to and from your place of business. Everyone needs to get to and from work, no matter what their work is (or whether they are employed or in business), and the cost of getting to work (and the choice of the transportation method) is a personal one.

To summarize so far, in order for an expense to be deductible it:

  • Must be reasonable,
  • Must be incurred for the purpose of producing income,
  • Must NOT be a capital expense,
  • Must NOT be related to earning exempt income, and
  • Must NOT be a personal or living expense.

The next article will discuss limits on a set of specific expenses.

About the Author

pro-tip

Pro Tip

ACCESSING THE SMALL BUSINESS DEDUCTION IN YOUR BUSINESS

The Small Business Deduction gives businesses a tax deduction on the first $500,000 of income. This saves an eligible corporation around up to $50,000 in income taxes. There are a number of conditions that have to be met to be eligible for this deduction.

BARAN SOLMAZ
BARAN SOLMAZ
1717778800
i can confidently say that Sam Faris is the best out there who can handle problems with the CRA. he helped me to resolve a complicated and massive audits with my companies and got me the best results. he did a perfect reorganization after and now feel i am well protected having him on board.
I approached Sam Faris as I had a complicated case with the CRA regarding my residency status. Sam has performed a detailed and in depth analysis and submitted his findings to the CRA. In conclusion, Sam was able to convince the CRA that I am not a resident and I did not have to file tax returns in Canada. Super happy with Sam service and of course with the outcome.
Essam Alftayh
Essam Alftayh
1717274326
Sam Faris filed my many years of outstanding tax returns under the voluntary disclosure program. As a result, significant penalties were waived and more importantly the my many years of sleepless nights and living in fear are over now. Thank you Sam and I highly recommend him to family and friends.
D Schrager
D Schrager
1717025313
Sam of Faris CPA is an expert with CRA issues. I have waisted significant amount of money by hiring other professionals who never delivered. Sam’s promises are solid and he never disappointed me. Sam’s work quality exceeds expectations. Many thanks Sam and I will absolutely recommend your service to family and friends.
Before hiring Faris CPA, I shopped around and I hired a CPA firm who offered significantly cheaper fee than Faris CPA. I must admit that this was a mistake. That firm promised the moon and they did not deliver. I learned by accident that the firm outsourced my file to a firm in India. I was very upset as I did not consent to have my returns done in India. I lost trust in the firm as the firm mislead me by making me believe that my file is being handled properly and efficiently by CPAs who are knowledgeable in Canadian taxes. I had to fire them immediately and hired Faris CPA. Sam Faris and his team dealt with my case efficiently and on timely basis. As a result, my many years of outstanding personal and corporate tax returns have been filed as promised. The taxes that I ended up owing are way less than what I expected. Sam Faris and his team performed a good tax planning strategy which saved me taxes. Faris CPA fee is very reasonable considering the quality of work that has been delivered and the tax saving that was achieved.Don’t hire a firm who provides cheaper fee as you will end up paying twice. In my situation, I ended up paying to a firm who outsourced my file to India and I came back and hired Faris to complete the job properly. Save your money, time and emotions and hire Faris CPA and they will get the job done to your satisfaction.
Kate Miller
Kate Miller
1716575760
Thanks Sam for your help with our CRA issues. You were very easy to contact and deal with and did what was needed very quickly. Thanks so much.
It was my pleasure to work with Sam Faris closely to resolve my tax issue with the CRA. Sam was efficient and resolved it to my satisfaction. Unlike other professionals that I dealt with regarding the same tax matter, whatever he promised, he delivered with the least time and with a reasonable fee. Thanks Sam for all your help.
Lisa Lisa
Lisa Lisa
1716551738
I highly recommend Sam--he is a true expert--knowledgeable and professional. He is highly skilled, quick to respond, and an expert at any CRA matter. I honestly don't know where I would be without having hired him. Five stars for sure.
Rob Miller
Rob Miller
1716489740
Sam responded very quickly to my request for his assistance with my CRA submission. We spoke by zoom. He then processed the paperwork and has submitted it straight away. I would thoroughly recommend Sam to people anywhere in Canada who needs timely and efficient help with their tax issue.
Rasha Makhoul
Rasha Makhoul
1716055095
Faris CPA helped me to navigate a very difficult tax matter. I would recommend the firm to anyone who needs tax experts with high business standards.
Sam is a kind man and gave me honest advice! Was very easy to get a consultation as well!
Luba A
Luba A
1715083762
Very impressive. I wish I met Sam many years back. He would have saved us money and saved our time from dealing with professionals who promised the moon but never delivered. Thanks Sam for all your help. You deserve every dollar you charged us.
Lila Saba
Lila Saba
1715012850
Highly recommend Mr. Faris for any problem with the CRA. He is efficient and creative and has his own strategies to get favorable results. Thanks Sam for alll your help.
Shadi Hakawaty
Shadi Hakawaty
1714936992
I was referred to Mr Faris by a friend of mine who happened to be his client for more than 10 years .I was struggling with the CRA regarding HST audit .CRA claimed that I owe significant amount of hst .Mr Faris was able to preform a detailed analysis which is backed up with previous court cases .as a result mr FARIS was able to convince CRA that the property was not subject to hst and the case was closed with zero hst owing.Thank you mr FARIS for all your hard work 🙏
Rosa hanna
Rosa hanna
1714918257
Sam Faris helped me and helped my family to deal with a very complex audit with the CRA. His performance exceeded expectations and his fee is reasonable.
Kevin Eatz
Kevin Eatz
1710287499
Was very professional and fast with helping me file taxes that I have missed over the years. Highly recommend :)
Ria Frith
Ria Frith
1709742935
Excellent service! Sam helped make a stressful, complicated situation much easier to deal with, showing great patience and compassion. I'm very grateful.
farshid tayyeb
farshid tayyeb
1709600147
Sam and his team helped me with filing my complicated corporate tax. He is very informative, and knowledgable and most importantly always available to answer your questions and concerns. He is very detailed and spent a lot of time preparing my tax file and fixing my previous accountant’s mistakes. I should also mention that his fee was very fair. Thank you so much Sam!
Vero Land
Vero Land
1708810543
Had a meeting with Sam regarding my tax matter with the CRA. Sam was informative and provided an excellent advice to handle the situation.
David Kline
David Kline
1708785450
CRA audited me based on net worth audit. This audit lasted almost 2 years. I suffered emotionally and financially as a result. Bringing Sam and his team into the picture was the best decision that I have ever made. Sam followed a very unique strategy which led to dropping the taxes to my satisfaction. Thanks Sam for all your hard work.
Tomer Pitel
Tomer Pitel
1708694932
I wish I met Sam of Faris CPA many years ago. He would have saved me lots of money and kept me out of troubles with the CRA. His performance exceeded expectations. 10 stars
Madison Wortman
Madison Wortman
1708657850
Sam is the man to handle any CRA dispute. Very happy with his services and the results that he achieved for me.
Gwen Meador
Gwen Meador
1708535537
Sam Faris helped me with the HST audit which involved building a new houses. CRA proposed to assess the houses that I built higher than it should be. Sam approach was convincing and knock down the assessment significantly. Thanks to Sam that I did not have to file objection and the issue was settled at the audit stage with the least cost.
Rafa Vargas
Rafa Vargas
1706749169
Hire Sam if you have any tax issue with the CRA. He is highly reliable and trust worthy and will absolutely look after your best interest. Mark my word on this as this is based on my recent experience having Sam dealing with my issue with the CRA.
Joseph Qassis
Joseph Qassis
1706481745
Extremely helpful and high work ethics. Thank you for all your help Sam for solving my tax issues.
NewLeaf Dental
NewLeaf Dental
1706381674
I was referred to Sam Faris by a tax lawyer in the city. Sam helped me with a very complicated tax audit by the CRA. Results exceeded expectations and now I can focused more in my business as Sam is defending me with the CRA problems.
John S
John S
1706380825
Best CPA and tax expert in the country. Sam helped me with a very complicated tax problem which involved voluntary disclosure. CRA accepted Sam argument and submission without a single question asked. He saved me the penalties and interest. Highly recommend Sam and his team.
Loris Layus
Loris Layus
1706153940
Very happy with Sam services. Sam helped me to resolve a complex tax audit by CRA. Results exceeded expectations and highly recommend Sam and his team.
Angela Simpson
Angela Simpson
1705181007
Great experience, very informative, and knowledgable!
Sam Faris helped us with a serious matter with CRA. He is extremely knowledgeable, efficient and more importantly has very high work standards. I would highly recommend Sam to anyone who is facing an issue with CRA.
Rey459
Rey459
1704088130
Sam helped me with a very difficult tax issue which involved voluntary disclosure. He submitted a perfect package where CRA did not bother to ask any question. My package was approved from the first time with no issue at all. I must admit that after shopping around, Sam’s fee was the most reasonable fee among all the professionals including 2 tax law firms. Thank you Sam for all your hard work.
Soysal Realty
Soysal Realty
1704086408
A trusted tax firm who handled my complicated tax problems perfectly with the least cost. Sam and his team exceeded expectation. Highly recommend.
Waseem Khoury
Waseem Khoury
1702982945
Luckily I was referred to Sam and his team by a friend of mine. After wasting time and money with a tax lawyer, finding Sam was a big relief. He was able to resolve my tax issue with CRA on timely basis and with the least cost. Many thanks Sam.
maria martins
maria martins
1702833053
Super professional with high work and ethics standards. Highly recommend Sam and his team. Thanks for the hard work.
Seth Woodard
Seth Woodard
1702580217
Sam was super helpful and responsive, extremely fast, and very easy to work with. Would recommend to anyone. Thanks Sam!
MARIA FUDA
MARIA FUDA
1701962330
Without doubts, the team at Faris CPA is the best out there to dispute CRA decisions. They are focused on details and are second to none. Their fee is fair and more importantly, they are honest, reliable and meeting their promises. Don't bother to hire other professionals and of course no need for tax lawyers who charge you excessive legal fees. Hire Sam and his team and they can get the job perfectly done and on a timely basis with the least cost. Very grateful to Sam for all the hard work on my file. I am lucky to know you and because of you, I have no concerns whatsoever if CRA tries to attack me and attack my business in the future.Thank you Sam.Maria Fuda,Litewave Communications
Paulina R
Paulina R
1701920055
Very helpful and super efficient. Sam is an expert with tax problems and will help you in every aspect with the least cost. Thank you so much for all your hard work!!
jonathan sousa
jonathan sousa
1701786708
Sam is a wealth of knowledge. I would highly recommend his services to friends and family.
Scott Dalziel
Scott Dalziel
1701716742
Sam and Edward were extremely helpful and very timely in providing their services! They provided great service at a very reasonable price.
David Lonergan
David Lonergan
1701716732
Sam Faris and his team are EXPERTS in fighting the CRA / Canada Revenue Agency. I cannot say enough good things! Save your money and don’t hire a tax lawyer. They can do it ALL and save you the legal fees. Sam and Team will get you the best outcome for a very reasonable fee. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
Colin Simpson
Colin Simpson
1701454466
Sam Faris is an excellent accountant who is an expert in CRA issues. He is very knowledgeable and I highly recommend him.
Very professional and high work ethics.
Ryan Butao
Ryan Butao
1700422012
Ana Santos
Ana Santos
1699467169
Amazing work and great exceptional service.
Edden Y
Edden Y
1699118104
Sam Faris is highly professional and keep his promises. He promised me a fair resolution to my tax issue and he met the promise. His fee is very reasonable too.
Steve Hayward
Steve Hayward
1699045891
Sam helped me out with a complicated (to me) tax issue I had. He was super responsive and walked me through everything. I had a follow up question a few months later and he responded within an hour. Highly recommended.
Marcin J
Marcin J
1698918573
Very professional support for international taxes.
Gol Zar
Gol Zar
1696091250
Sam is extremely knowledgeable with tax issues with CRA. He provided me the best advice which saved me from troubles. His fee is reasonable too. Thank you Sam and I will recommend you to my people.
peter lozier
peter lozier
1694887202
I had the absolute pleasure of working with Sam Faris and I can't express enough how thrilled I am with the service I received. From start to finish, the experience was seamless and efficient.Sam is a true expert in Canadian tax regulations. he demonstrated an impressive knowledge of the Canadian tax code, which immediately put my mind at ease. He was able to answer all my questions and provide valuable insights that helped immensely with Canadian tax laws.What truly sets Sam apart is their incredible speed and attention to detail. I submitted my tax documents, and he worked diligently to complete my return in record time, all while ensuring it complied with the Canadian tax requirements. I was amazed at how swiftly they turned around my taxes without sacrificing accuracy. It's evident that he has a deep understanding of the Canadian tax system and can navigate it with ease.Throughout the entire process, Sam was not only professional but also incredibly personable. They made what is typically a stressful time of year into a stress-free experience. Their friendly demeanor and willingness to explain complex Canadian tax concepts in simple terms made me feel valued as a client.
Nadine Mortada
Nadine Mortada
1694778156
I received the best tax advice for my international tax issue. Thank you Sam for all your help.
Shams Hirji
Shams Hirji
1693968913
Sam is the most trusted advisor amd accountant in personal and corporate accounting. Creative CRA resolution specialist. I highly recommend Sam.Call him today for all your issues !!
Haifa Rizk
Haifa Rizk
1693766122
Sam Faris has provided me with he best solution to dispute CRA audit. I highly recommend Sam for any tax problem.
Ercan Coşkun
Ercan Coşkun
1692485940
Sam is the right guy to fight CRA. Sam helped me to resolve a serious issue with CRA. He went above and beyond and got me the best results. 10 stars
Sam helped me with the voluntary disclosure program to file all my outstanding tax returns. He saved me taxes and penalties and his fee is very reasonable. I highly recommend him to any problems with CRA.
Next Reviewsjs_loader