We solve serious CRA tax problems

The General Anti-Avoidance Rule

The general rule in Canadian taxation is that a taxpayer is free to arrange his or her affairs in a way that minimized the total taxes he or she is liable to pay. In other words, to order his or her affairs to lower the overall tax burden. This is the essence of tax planning.

This general rule is modified by principles of law, including by the General Anti-Avoidance Rule. The General Anti-Avoidance Rule (“GAAR”) is one that is applied to the whole of the taxing statute, and not to particular actions or parts. Just remember, there are specific anti-avoidance rules that may apply to your particular circumstances. That said, the GAAR is the focus of this article.

The GAAR is a provision of last resort that allows the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) to modify the tax consequences of otherwise valid and enforceable tax planning. The GARR only works in very narrow circumstances and only when the government can meet the pre-conditions. The pre-conditions can be summarized as a series of questions that have to be answered in the affirmative before the GAAR can apply. They are:

  1. Was there a tax benefit to the taxpayer as a result of the event or transaction?
  2. Was the event or transaction that gave rise to this tax benefit an “avoidance transaction”?
  3. Was the “avoidance transaction” giving rise to the tax benefit a misuse or abuse of the object, spirit, or purpose a particular provision or the whole statute?

In most cases the first question is easily answered “Yes”, as the CRA would not be pursuing a taxpayer unless they imagine a different way of structuring the transaction or events that would give rise to more tax being payable. The battle between taxpayer and the taxman, in most cases, is over questions 2 and 3.

The details of whether a transaction is an “avoidance transaction” or whether or not the transaction is a misuse or abuse of the object, spirit, or purpose of the tax law is difficult to answer in most cases and well beyond the scope of this article. However, as a general rule, if the transactions or series of transactions were entered into primarily for a valid business reason and not a tax reason, the transaction will not be an “avoidance transaction”. Similarly, where the outcome is exactly what the law intended or matches the policy that was promoted or intended to be promoted by the law, then it is not going to be an abuse or misuse of the object, spirit, or purpose of the tax law. Other than these two clear cut cases, there is a great deal of grey area that taxpayers and the CRA can and do fight over.

Where the CRA meets its burden, they can modify the tax outcomes to ones that would have existed had the avoidance transactions not taken place. This can result in significant tax, interest, and possibly penalties being assessed against the taxpayer.

About the Author

pro-tip

Pro Tip

ACCESSING THE SMALL BUSINESS DEDUCTION IN YOUR BUSINESS

The Small Business Deduction gives businesses a tax deduction on the first $500,000 of income. This saves an eligible corporation around up to $50,000 in income taxes. There are a number of conditions that have to be met to be eligible for this deduction.

Faris CPA was awesome! I cannot express how grateful I was during my tax audit.

Super kind and approachable- they took the time to explain the entire process. They answered all my questions/concerns and made sure I understood everything.

They made sure nothing was overlooked and would keep in touch with me should they need any docs as well as asked me questions to ensure accuracy.

I really appreciated their dedication and expertise! For anything tax-related, I truly recommend Faris CPA.
Response from the owner:Thank you Donald for your five stars review. We will remain at your disposal if you need our services in the future.
Great experience dealing with Sam Faris and his team. They were transparent, patient with their explanations and they meet all promises. Highly reliable and trustworthy firm. They promise and they meet all their promises. If you are looking for the best tax consultant firm, I highly recommend Faris CPA.
Response from the owner:Many thanks and much appreciated for the kind and positive review.
Sam Faris is a consummate professional whose expertise, clarity, and warmth make him worth every penny. If you need clear answers and effective solutions for complex situations, he’s your go-to.

I only write reviews when they’re truly deserved, and after meeting with Sam, I’m compelled to share my experience. I’m meticulous about researching professionals before reaching out, and Sam exceeded my expectation.

From the moment I arrived for a consultation on a nuanced issue, Sam greeted me with a warm yet focused demeanor that instantly put me at ease. He was fully present, diving into my situation with laser-like attention.  As I explained my case, he listened intently, then walked me through each aspect with clear, concise expertise, pausing to ensure I had no questions before moving forward. His ability to break down complexity into actionable insights was remarkable.

What stood out most was his honesty and confidence. He calmly assured me that my situation, while intricate, was well within his expertise—backed by his extensive track record of handling far more complex cases. His steady presence and thorough understanding left me feeling reassured.

Sam's stellar reputation, reflected in his consistent high reviews, is no fluke. He’s the real deal: an upstanding professional whose integrity and skill are rare in today’s world. If you’re facing a challenging situation and need straightforward answers, reassurance, and results, contact Faris.
Response from the owner:It has been pleasure working with you and feel free to contact us in the future for any further help needed.
Thank you for all your help. Reliable and highly professional firm.
Response from the owner:Thank you for the positive review.